Levin Report

“Pro-Life” Idaho Republicans Declare Women Should Be Left to Die to Save Fetuses

Abortion is apparently “murder,” but letting pregnant people die is cool.
Image may contain Clinic Hospital Operating Theatre Human Person Furniture and Bed
Sean Gallup/Getty Images

A frequent refrain from gaslighting conservatives in the weeks since Roe v. Wade was overturned goes something like this: “Abortion hasn’t been outlawed, the Supreme Court is just returning the decision to the states. Don’t be so hysterical.” While technically true, in practice, this argument is, of course, total bullshit. Abortion has now been restricted in roughly half the country, eight states banned the medical procedure the day Roe was struck down, and 13 states will forbid it within 30 days of the June 24 ruling. If someone tries to claim to you that the Court’s decision wasn’t that big a deal and/or doesn’t change much, you are legally obligated to inform them they have shit where their brain should be. If you can stand to breathe the same air as them for a moment longer, you should also inform them of the many ways the various states in question have proceeded to use the opportunity afforded to them by the Supreme Court to advocate for not only forced births, but the state-sanctioned murder of pregnant people.

Over the weekend, the Idaho Republican Party voted against adopting an amendment that would have added an exception to its official policy on abortion for cases to save the life of the mother. Scott Herndon, a Republican running unopposed for a state Senate seat, argued to delegates that “for the last 49 years we have essentially lost the argument in the culture because we have focused on abortion as the termination of a pregnancy and not the termination of a living human being.” He added: “We will never win this human rights issue, the greatest of our time, if we make allowances for the intentional killing of another human being.” Obviously, he did not note that withholding life-saving care from a pregnant person, knowing they could die, is also an intentional killing, because that would apparently require too much reflection on his part. The decision not to add an abortion exception to save the life of the mother was decided 412-164; as The Independent notes, the party platform “is used to direct policy within the state’s GOP-controlled legislature.”

Currently, Idaho’s “trigger” law, passed in 2020, outlaws abortions with exceptions for rape and incest, though only if the crimes are reported to law enforcement. (The Idaho GOP platform has no exceptions for rape or incest; a regional Planned Parenthood organization and an Idaho abortion provider have sued to block the law and a hearing is scheduled for August 3.) According to Newsweek, in a Facebook video after the Supreme Court struck down Roe, Herndon declared, “you don’t put to death the innocent child for the crime of its father, but that’s what this [trigger] law would allow.” He also claimed that such exceptions give women “a free pass,” and said that “if a mother really wants to kill her child, she could lie, say she was raped, file a police report, and go get her child killed in the state of Idaho and nobody would be prosecuted.” Because Herndon apparently wanted to make it abundantly clear that not only is he anti-abortion, he’s also a colossal asshole too. (On his website, Herndon says he “believes in preserving and protecting human life” and “has followed this in word and deed as an active Abortion Abolitionist and Pro-Gun advocate.” We’re going to guess that no, he doesn’t see the irony.)

Elsewhere in reports of horrifying repercussions from the Supreme Court merely kicking the abortion question to the states, a woman bled for more than 10 days after suffering an incomplete miscarriage because a Wisconsin hospital wouldn’t perform the procedure; a woman with an ectopic pregnancy had to seek emergency, out-of-state care because a doctor in her home state was worried he’d run afoul of the law; administrators at a Kansas City, Missouri hospital temporarily required “pharmacist approval” before prescribing medications that stop postpartum hemorrhages—as in hemorrhages that occur after someone has given birth—because they are also sometimes used for abortions; and a 10-year-old rape victim in Ohio was told they must give birth to their rapist’s child or seek care elsewhere.

If you would like to receive the Levin Report in your inbox daily, click here to subscribe.

But wait, there’s more

Twitter content

This content can also be viewed on the site it originates from.

Ted Cruz wants same-sex marriage ruling overturned

Luckily for the Texas senator, marriage between humans and gelatinous tube worms is not on the line, otherwise he and Heidi would have to start thinking about moving abroad. Per CNN:

Obergefell, like Roe v. Wade, ignored two centuries of our nation’s history,” Cruz said in a clip posted on his YouTube channel for his podcast. “Marriage was always an issue that was left to the states. We saw states before Obergefell, some states were moving to allow gay marriage, other states were moving to allow civil partnerships. There were different standards that the states were adopting.”

He added: “The way the Constitution set up for you to advance that position is convince your fellow citizens, that if you succeeded in convincing your fellow citizens, then your state would change the laws to reflect those views. In Obergefell, the court said, ‘No, we know better than you guys do, and now every state must, must sanction and permit gay marriage…. I think that decision was clearly wrong when it was decided,” Cruz said. ‘It was the court overreaching.”

In June, in a concurring opinion to Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health, the case the court used as a pretext to overturn Roe, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that the court’s conservative goon squad should now think about scrapping the rulings that protect contraception, same-sex marriage, and same-sex sexual activity. So this isn’t just Cruz taking up oxygen, but an actual, real threat.

No, really: Imagine it!

Twitter content

This content can also be viewed on the site it originates from.

Elsewhere!

Donald Trump Should Never Be Allowed Within 1,000 Feet of the White House Again: A Pocket Guide (V.F.)

WHO warns COVID “nowhere near over” as variants spike in U.S., Europe (The Washington Post)

Fauci Says He Will “Almost Certainly” Retire by January 2025 (NYT)

Roberts clears way for Indiana to try to implement law restricting abortion access for minors (CNN)

The Case of the Missing January 6 Secret Service Texts (Intelligencer)

Report on Uvalde Shooting Finds “Systemic Failures” in Police Response (NYT)

“A uniquely dangerous tool”: How Google’s data can help states track abortions (Politico)

It’s So Hot in the U.K. That Airport Runways Are Melting (Intelligencer)

Steve Bannon Is Looking Pretty Defenseless as His Contempt Trial Over Jan. 6 Is Set to Begin (V.F.)

Vito Corleone’s Godfather mansion up for rent on Airbnb (NYP)

Skittles “unfit for human consumption,” California lawsuit claims (LA Times)